Singer 4423 vs Brother ST371HD: Which Sewing Machine Should You Buy?

Quick Summary of Brother ST371HD vs Singer 4423

Trying to decide between the Singer 4423 and the Brother St371Hd? Let’s break down their features.

Model	Singer 4423	Brother ST371HD
Brand	Singer	Brother
Built-in Stitches	23	37
Stitch Speed (SPM)	1100	800
Weight	14.6 lbs	18.4 lbs
Machine Type	Mechanical	Mechanical
Needle Positions	Adjustable	Adjustable
Buttonhole Styles	1-step	1-step
Presser Foot Pressure	Yes	No
Bobbin System	Top drop-in	Top drop-in
Best For	Heavy fabrics	Heavy fabrics
Warranty	25-year limited	25-year limited
Price Range	Mid-range	Mid-range

Overview of Singer 4423 and Brother ST371HD

Singer 4423

Think of the Singer 4423 as your no-nonsense sewing partner. It’s fast, powerful, and reliable—the kind of machine you can count on for both quick repairs and long weekend projects. The motor is stronger than most in its class, and the stainless steel bedplate keeps fabric gliding smoothly. Whether you’re making garments or home decor, its range of stitches and buttonhole function covers the essentials. It’s especially well-suited for crafters, side-hustlers, or anyone looking for a tough machine on a budget.

Pros:

• The Singer 4423 combines speed and power, making it ideal for both beginners and seasoned sewists.
• Features a top drop-in bobbin for hassle-free threading and easy monitoring.
• Designed to handle layered fabrics without jamming or skipping stitches.

Cons:

• No speed control slider, which can make it harder for beginners to manage precision at high speed.
• Noisy operation at full speed due to the powerful motor.

Brother ST371HD

Designed for both flexibility and toughness, the Brother ST371HD handles a wide fabric range—from silks to tough materials like canvas. With 37 built-in stitch types and a one-step buttonhole feature, it supports a variety of tasks, including mending, quilting, and decorative stitching. The machine includes several presser feet to enhance its function, such as a nonstick foot for tricky fabrics. Compact but powerful, this model is a great option for users who want durability without moving to an industrial-grade machine.

Pros:

• Designed for tough fabrics, including canvas and denim.
• Comes with 37 stitches and 6 presser feet, adding great versatility.
• Good balance of power and user-friendliness.

Cons:

• Slightly less powerful motor compared to some heavy-duty Singer models.
• Not ideal for detailed decorative sewing or embroidery.
• Doesn’t include speed control or a computerized interface.

Key Differences

Brother ST371HD has 37 built-in stitches, offering more variety than the Singer 4423, which has 23.
Brother ST371HD comes with six presser feet, while the Singer 4423 includes fewer.
Singer 4423 has a slightly stronger motor and handles thick fabrics more consistently.

Which One Should You Choose?

If you need a machine that handles both light and heavy fabrics with a good variety of stitches, the Brother ST371HD is a solid option. For maximum power and speed, particularly with thick layers, the Singer 4423 is the stronger performer.

FAQs